.

And by a prudent flight and cunning save A life which valour could not, from the grave. A better buckler I can soon regain, But who can get another life again? Archilochus

Friday, May 22, 2026

Marcel Mauss: A Century of Symbolic Gift Giving

The 'Gift' of 9/11
The twin towers were not destroyed by terrorists. The twin towers committed suicide. They collapsed under their own weight. When the two towers collapsed, you had the impression that they were responding to the suicide of the suicide planes with their own suicide. It has been said that even God cannot declare war on himself. Well he can. The West in the position of God, divine omnipotence and absolute moral legitimacy has become suicidal and declared war on itself.

-Jean Baudrillard, "The Spirit of Terrorism"

from Google AI:

Continental Philosophy (The Event as Rupture)
In Continental philosophy, an "event" is often viewed as a sudden, unpredictable rupture or breakthrough that changes everything—it alters how we perceive truth, language, or history.
  • Alain Badiou: A French philosopher who defines an event as an unpredictable, ground-breaking rupture that brings forth new truths. According to Badiou, an event shatters established norms and forces individuals to take a leap of faith to remain faithful to this new truth (e.g., a revolutionary political movement or falling in love).
  • Gilles Deleuze: Drawing from the ancient Stoics, Deleuze viewed events as "incorporeal" entities. Rather than physical actions, events are the meaning or sense of what happens, which subsist at the surface of things and transform how we understand ourselves and our realities.
  • Martin Heidegger: In his later work (Contributions to Philosophy), Heidegger conceptualizes the event (or Ereignis) as a moment of appropriation, where human beings and the meaning of "Being" come into a mutually revealing relationship.

The End of Pure Positivity

The 3 Social  Obligations of Gift Exchanges
1. Give Gifts
2  Receive Gifts
3  Make Worthy Return of a Received Gift (Hau)

Capitalism is an "equal" gift exchange that obscures/ hides/ eliminates the future social obligation through its' pure "equality" and satisfaction of the 3 social obligations of gift giving stated above.  In such an exchange, there is no sacrifice on the part of the giver.  There is also no surplus generated on the part of the receiver.  Thirdly, there is immediate satisfaction with no future obligation to establish/ disestablish (or signify) the social bond between the parties to the exchange.  There is no time delay that extends the bond's duration, just an immediate cui pro quo (absent a contract to extend credit).

That, and all the terms for "worthy return" are directly/contractually explicitly spelled out.  Taxes paid in return for State Protection of self or property from State seizure.  Installment payments for goods received.  All aimed at achieving a parity of exchange that states and meets the specific terms of the immediate social obligation (and infers no future others, unlike the bonds of a vassal to his Lord, or a marriage bond joining two families w/o a dowry or bride price paid).  The "worthiness" of the gift (hau, as in "haunt") exchanged is not undetermined/ left "open", and meant to exist only in the minds of whom the gift was exchanged to imagine an  yet unspecified "worthy" return.  One requiring sacrifice and adding a surplus to make it more "worthy".

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't get your recent arguments...
Sorry.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

They were thoughts I was having early into watching the video for the first time. I'm still not completely through it. I think I have to understand Durkheim more, first before trying to make more sense of Mauss.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

...which is all a continuation of trying to understand Bataille and the concept of the General Economy.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

Baudrillard deconstructs 9/11 in semiotic terms. The twin towers of the World Trade Center had a specific symbology. NYC skyline represented a general competition of buildings for height. The WTC was not just one tower, but 2, of equal height (signifying "monopoly"). The attack was a "gift" in that it destroyed the monopoly, and in return, the West turned their eyes "inward" in a self-destructive act (aka - The Patriot Act" that made everyone a suspected "terrorist"... the "suicide of the West"). That is the "worthy return" (gift) of the West BACK to Islam. AN acknowledgement of the "sacredness" of religion" *sacrifice and surplus") vs the "profaneness" of commerce ("equal" gift exchanges)... Equality of gift exchanges destroy the social bonds between community members. The social bond relies upon NOT knowing in advance exactly what needs to be returned in exchange for the gift, but a social compulsion to return with a "surplus" signifying the strength of the gift giver (and social status).

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

The West has "lost" its' "Christian" Spirit. That of "Caritas" (it has been replaced with "suspicion" and Total State surveillance). DARPA's "Total Information Awareness" (TIA) project has been replaced with Peter Thiel's/ Alex Karp's PALANTIR and the "free" market with the directed market of Search (Google) and Tribute (Amazon).

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

America no longer "gifts" its' allies with Defense protection. It now demands a "worthy return" for it's gifts.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

The feudal lord demands the "services" of his vassals. The "Rules based Order" with all its' contractual "certainty" has been replaced with uncertainty, and the social obligations associated with allies making a "worthy return". Will the US then offer worthy return BACK to its' allies if they make one? Uncertain... but such is the "nature" of tribal cooperation/ confederacy.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

The "entitlement" (commercial) feelings of the recipients of America's Rules Based Order policies have been destroyed. A "worthy return" (WWIII) is now demanded. A potlatch and general bonfire of the vanities. The objet petite 'a of commercial relations must pay tribute to the Objet Grand 'A of social relations.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

...so that all parties can recommit to pursuing the former (parity-based commercial relations)

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

Capitalism is religion, secularized. A gift must be offered. A gift must be received. The gift receiver MUST make a "worthy return".

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

In commerce, there is no "obligation" to receive the gift. It is "haggled" over and the obligation to make worthy return immediately satisfied (lessening the social bond that would otherwise remain). The "debt" owed is formalized/ contractualized.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

Gift giving establishes a "moral" economy. Commerce is amoral.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

Gift giving involves moral luxuries, surpluses and debts (the sacred). Commerce serves to satisfy amoral "necessities" (the profane).

Anonymous said...

Yeah. And "loyalty to brand", and all Marketing... do not exist.)))

Well, If that is your choice -- to read Gel-Man's newspapers... how I can deny you.

Anonymous said...

For example... if you'd read something like -- that steam engine working on self-(e)steam of a ship engineer -- would you give it so much attention, and woukd not treat it as staunch bs right away???

Anonymous said...

//America no longer "gifts" its' allies with Defense protection. It now demands a "worthy return" for it's gifts.

Demanded gifts... not called "gifts"...

yawn.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

Never heard of a bridal registry?

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

GARAP! A pure signifier.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

Enjoy!

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

I love parody. This whole blogsite runs on the self-esteam of a ship engineer....

Anonymous said...

Yeah???
Especially when top man think that that parody is not parody at all, but real deal -- and demand of you to show self-esteam and run that damn thing... instead of loading bunkers with coal or tanks with gas??? %^)))))

And that EXACTLY what ruins empires -- top brass start BELIEVING their own propaganda
(and I saw it from inside -- when Gorbachov ruined USSR... because he foolishly believrd that talking truth and allowing to tell truth... is the way to rule))(((