On Cultures of Entitled Victimhood
Does Unconditionally Affirming Victims Have Consequences?
Maternal microchimerism (MMc) is the persistence of a small population of a mother's cells inside the body of her offspring. [1, 2]How It Happens
- Bidirectional trafficking: During pregnancy, cells move back and forth across the placenta. While fetal cells enter the mother (fetal microchimerism), maternal cells also enter the developing fetus (maternal microchimerism). [1, 2, 3, 4]
- Breastfeeding: After birth, maternal cells present in breast milk can cross the infant's gastrointestinal tract and migrate into various tissues. [1]
Where They Go
- Blood and bone marrow
- The immune system
- The brain and central nervous system [1]
Biological and Health Implications
- Immune education and tolerance: Exposure to maternal cells (often referred to as Non-Inherited Maternal Antigens, or NIMA) helps train the infant's immune system, promoting regulatory T cells (Tregs) and lifelong immune tolerance. [1, 2]
- Development and protection: Maternal cells can differentiate into functional cell types in the offspring, potentially aiding in immune defense, tissue homeostasis, and early protection against infections. [1, 2]
- Autoimmunity and disease links: While mostly a normal physiological process, persistent foreign cells have also been studied for potential roles in auto-inflammatory or autoimmune condition.

No, inbreeding is generally not better at combatting local diseases. In fact, extensive scientific evidence shows that inbreeding significantly weakens the immune system and decreases resistance to both local (endemic) and novel pathogens. [1, 2]While there is a nuanced evolutionary hypothesis regarding historical adaptation, the overall genetic costs far outweigh the benefits.The Nuanced Exception: Co-adapted Gene ComplexesSome evolutionary biologists have noted a highly specific scenario where inbreeding could theoretically provide a narrow benefit. In historically isolated populations facing low dispersal of pathogens, restricted mating can preserve co-adapted gene complexes—specific combinations of genes that have evolved together to perfectly counter a highly localized, unchanging disease. Dispersing and outbreeding with an outside population can break up these specialized gene matches. [1]Why Inbreeding Fails to Protect Against DiseaseDespite that rare evolutionary trade-off, the biological reality of inbreeding typically results in a severe net negative for immune defense due to the following factors:
- Loss of Immune Diversity: The immune system (especially the Major Histocompatibility Complex, or MHC) relies entirely on genetic diversity to recognize a wide array of pathogens. Inbreeding causes homozygosity—meaning an offspring inherits identical copies of immune genes from both parents. This severely limits the breadth of diseases the immune system can identify and fight off. [1, 2]
- The Single-Disease Trap: Even if a highly inbred individual accidentally achieves a perfect genetic combination to resist one specific local parasite, they become profoundly vulnerable to almost everything else. A slight mutation in the local disease or the introduction of a new pathogen can easily wipe out the entire population due to a lack of genetic variance. [1, 2]
- Inbreeding Depression: Studies on various species (ranging from guppies to livestock) consistently show that inbred populations suffer from slower recovery rates and higher mortality when exposed to native, local pathogens. [1, 2]
- Accumulation of Genetic Defects: Inbreeding forces dangerous, hidden recessive mutations to express themselves. The physiological stress of dealing with congenital defects, physical deformities, or lower base fitness further degrades an organism's capacity to survive an infectious disease outbreak. [1, 2, 3]
Inbreeding vs. Outbreeding Comparison
Feature Inbred Population Outbred / Mixed Population Immune System Scope Narrow; may fight one local strain well but vulnerable to others. Broad; equipped with diverse tools to recognize various pathogens. Response to New Mutants Poor; lack of genetic flexibility can cause rapid population crashes. Strong; genetic diversity allows at least some individuals to survive and adapt. Overall Fitness Load High; plagued by recessive disorders and lower baseline vitality. Low; harmful recessive mutations remain safely masked by healthy dominant genes. Ultimately, maximizing genetic diversity remains the premier biological defense mechanism against disease.
This was of course the subject of Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed's Study while a medical student.
"We shape our tools and thereafter our tools shape us."
- Marshall McLuhan
0:00 Intro: Catherine Liu on her new book Traumatised0:44 ‘It’s not a book written just to provoke’4:35 How trauma culture began: Oprah, self-help and the death of feminism6:45 The Boston women's health book and the fetish for vulnerability9:34 Why are privileged students the ‘most traumatised’?10:47 Self-diagnosis as status symbol15:38 Endurance vs. victimhood: how working-class communities handle pain17:59 The dark side: opioids, Purdue and West Virginia19:25 Oxford ADHD vs. a mining town on incapacity benefit20:57 The infantilised political subject25:30 Why did the left fall for it? Kant, Marx and May ’6829:50 From the new left to Silicon Valley self-optimisation33:34 Russell Group vs. redbrick: the class divide in ‘mental health’35:05 Is the culture war just class war from above?41:40 Welfare, work and dignity43:18 Race, anti-racism and the PMC45:57 Obama, the bank bailouts and symbolic politics47:51 ‘Intergenerational trauma’ and why she refuses it50:35 Ireland, famine memory and progress51:35 Can the left be saved?54:36 Outro
Immanuel Kant, "What is Enlightenment"