Complementarity: Reconciling the Tensor World of Space-Time w/ the Scalar/ Vector World of Matter

In physics, a scalar is a quantity with only magnitude (e.g., temperature, mass), a vector adds direction (e.g., velocity, force), and a tensor generalizes these, representing more complex relationships with multiple magnitudes and directions, with scalars as rank-0 tensors and vectors as rank-1 tensors. Tensors describe how physical properties (like stress or curvature) change across different directions, often represented by matrices (rank-2 tensors) or higher-dimensional arrays, transforming predictably under coordinate rotations.

from Google AI 1:

In modern physics, specifically Einstein's general relativity, the distinction is that the spacetime world is described by tensors, while the fundamental properties of matter are often described by scalar fields (among others). 

The Tensor Spacetime World

• Geometry as a Tensor: The physical world, in this framework, is a 4-dimensional manifold called spacetime. Its geometry and curvature are described by the metric tensor (a rank-two tensor).
• Gravity as Curvature: In general relativity, gravity is not a force but a manifestation of this spacetime curvature. The metric tensor determines how distances and time intervals are measured, which in turn defines how objects move in this curved space.
• Gravitational Waves: The way gravitational waves deform the fabric of space is purely tensorial in nature, with little room for scalar or vector components according to observations from detectors like LIGO. 

The Scalar Matter World

• Matter as a Source: Matter and energy are the sources of spacetime's curvature. The density and flux of energy and momentum are encapsulated in the stress-energy tensor (also a rank-two tensor).
• Scalar Fields: Fundamental properties of matter, like the mass of a particle, can be described by a scalar field (a rank-zero tensor). A scalar is a single value at each point in spacetime (e.g., temperature or height above sea level) that does not depend on the observer's coordinate system.
• Newtonian Limit: In classical physics, before Einstein, gravity was considered a scalar theory, where a gravitational force was derived from a scalar potential field dependent on mass. General relativity supersedes this, though it reduces to the Newtonian scalar theory in weak-field, low-speed limits. 

In summary, matter (described partly by scalar and other fields) dictates how spacetime (described by tensors, especially the metric tensor) curves, and spacetime tells matter how to move. 

from Google AI 2:

Bohr's Complementarity Principle states that quantum objects exhibit mutually exclusive but complementary properties (like wave-like or particle-like behavior, or position and momentum) that cannot be observed simultaneously; the experimental setup determines which aspect manifests, with both descriptions needed for a complete understanding, forming a core idea in the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. It explains that reality at the quantum level isn't a single picture but a totality of phenomena, where focusing on one property inherently limits knowledge of its complement, as seen in wave-particle duality.

Key Aspects of Complementarity: 

Wave-Particle Duality: A quantum entity can act as a wave (spread out, interfering) or a particle (localized, distinct), but not both in the same measurement. 

Context-Dependent Reality: The measuring apparatus dictates which property (wave or particle) is revealed; the system's behavior isn't independent of the experiment.

Mutually Exclusive Properties: Measuring one property (e.g., position) precisely prevents simultaneous measurement of its complementary property (e.g., momentum), as described by Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle. 

Complete Description: A full understanding requires considering both complementary descriptions, even though they seem contradictory, forming a more complete picture of reality than either alone.

Example: The Double-Slit Experiment 

When electrons pass through two slits, they create an interference pattern (wave-like). 

If detectors are placed at the slits to see which slit an electron goes through (particle-like), the interference pattern disappears, and electrons behave like particles.

Significance: 

Bohr saw complementarity as a fundamental limitation of human understanding and language when describing the quantum world, suggesting that classical concepts fail at this scale, necessitating this holistic, non-classical view.

More