.

And by a prudent flight and cunning save A life which valour could not, from the grave. A better buckler I can soon regain, But who can get another life again? Archilochus

Tuesday, September 15, 2026

Film Release Watch: The Pervert's Guide to Utopias

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

While history often remembers 31st U.S. President Herbert Hoover as a "do-nothing" leader during the onset of the Great Depression, modern scholars emphasize that his presidency was marked by a series of highly proactive, yet severely flawed economic, social, and political missteps. Rather than committing direct criminal misdeeds like some of his contemporary peers, Hoover’s "misdeeds" took the form of disastrous policy failures, civil rights suppressions, and aggressive military actions against American citizens.Below is an elaborate summary of the major controversies and missteps of the Hoover administration:1. The Bonus Army Crackdown (1932)The most politically damaging and widely condemned event of Hoover's presidency occurred in the summer of 1932.The Situation: Approximately 17,000 World War I veterans (the "Bonus Army") marched on Washington, D.C., to peacefully petition Congress for early payment of bonuses promised for their military service. Many camped with their families in makeshift shantytowns around the capital.The Crackdown: When the protest refused to clear out, Hoover ordered the military to evacuate the camps. General Douglas MacArthur severely exceeded his orders. He deployed infantry, cavalry, tanks, and bayonets, unleashing tear gas on veterans, women, and children. The shacks were burned to the ground.The Fallout: While Hoover did not intend for brute force to be used, he publicly defended the actions afterward, completely destroying what remained of his public image right before the 1932 presidential election.2. Disastrous Economic Policies & ProtectionismThough Hoover is often falsely accused of being entirely laissez-faire, he heavily intervened in the economy using counterproductive methods that worsened the Great Depression:The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act (1930): Against the urgent warnings of over 1,000 economists, Hoover signed the highest protective tariff in modern U.S. history. Intended to protect American businesses, it instead sparked international retaliation. Foreign markets closed, global trade plummeted, and the domestic economy collapsed further.The High-Wage Doctrine: Hoover pressured major industrial leaders to artificially freeze wages rather than allowing them to adjust to market conditions. This well-intentioned intervention effectively forced corporations to mass-layoff millions of workers because they could no longer afford payroll, driving unemployment toward 25%.


Anonymous said...

The Revenue Act of 1932: At the absolute worst point of the depression, Hoover signed a massive federal income tax hike to balance the budget. This completely stripped consumer spending power from the struggling public and further crippled corporate growth.3. Obstruction of Direct Federal Humanitarian ReliefBefore his presidency, Hoover was revered as a brilliant "Great Humanitarian" for coordinating post-WWI famine relief in Europe. Yet, as millions of Americans starved, his rigid ideological convictions backfired:Refusal of Direct Aid: Governed by the philosophy of "American Individualism," Hoover believed that direct federal handouts (a "dole") would rot the moral fabric of the country and foster government dependency.Corporate Bailouts over Public Aid: When he finally did authorize funding through the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) in 1932, the federal money went exclusively to stabilize banks, railroads, and corporations. It completely bypassed the poor and starving citizens who were overwhelming private charities. This gave the public an impression of systemic callousness and indifference.4. Severe Civil Rights & Racial MisstepsHoover’s administration engaged in several actions that severely harmed minority groups and marginalized communities:The "Mexican Repatriation" Program: In a bid to free up jobs for white Americans, the Hoover administration authorized the unconstitutional, forced deportation of an estimated 1 to 2 million people of Mexican descent. Shockingly, an estimated 60% of those deported were actually native-born U.S. citizens who were illegally rounded up and sent across the border.Suppression of Refugee Camp Realities (1927): Prior to his presidency, while leading relief for the Great Mississippi Flood of 1927, Hoover actively suppressed public reports detailing the horrific mistreatment, forced labor, and racial segregation of African American refugees in camp cities. He did this to protect his political prospects for the 1928 election.The Republican Party "Lily-White" Purge: Once in power, Hoover abandoned his progressive leanings on race to appeal to Southern white voters. He aggressively purged African Americans from leadership positions within the Republican Party, and continuously refused to back federal anti-lynching legislation.Summary of Historical LegacyHoover's legacy became synonymous with the absolute failure of governance during a crisis. Shantytowns became known as "Hoovervilles", empty turned-out pockets were "Hoover flags", and newspapers used for warmth were called "Hoover blankets". His rigid policy limits, disastrous interventions, and aggressive response to veterans ultimately led to one of the most lopsided electoral defeats in American history to Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932.